How to sum in MySQL recursive query
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
My problem statement is: I need to find places I can visit from Origin 'A' and their respective costs.
This is my table Train(Origin, Destination, LeastCost)
+--------+-------------+------+
| Origin | Destination | cost |
+--------+-------------+------+
| A | B | 1 |
| A | C | 4 |
| B | C | 2 |
| A | D | 4 |
+--------+-------------+------+
I have tried a query:
with recursive Final(Origin, Destination, LeastCost) As(
-> (Select * from Train)
-> UNION
-> (Select T.Origin, F.Destination, F.LeastCost
-> from Train T, Final F
-> where T.Destination = F.Origin))
-> select * from Final ;
This gives me:
+--------+-------------+-----------+
| Origin | Destination | LeastCost |
+--------+-------------+-----------+
| A | B | 1 |
| A | C | 4 |
| B | C | 2 |
| A | D | 4 |
| A | C | 2 |
+--------+-------------+-----------+
The result I am looking for is
Origin | Destination | Price |
A C 3
As A-->B = 1, B-->C=2 , So A-->C=1+2=3 in the last row.
How do I achieve this? I tried using SUM(LeastCost) inside the recursive query but MySQl doesn't allow aggregations in there.
mysql
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
My problem statement is: I need to find places I can visit from Origin 'A' and their respective costs.
This is my table Train(Origin, Destination, LeastCost)
+--------+-------------+------+
| Origin | Destination | cost |
+--------+-------------+------+
| A | B | 1 |
| A | C | 4 |
| B | C | 2 |
| A | D | 4 |
+--------+-------------+------+
I have tried a query:
with recursive Final(Origin, Destination, LeastCost) As(
-> (Select * from Train)
-> UNION
-> (Select T.Origin, F.Destination, F.LeastCost
-> from Train T, Final F
-> where T.Destination = F.Origin))
-> select * from Final ;
This gives me:
+--------+-------------+-----------+
| Origin | Destination | LeastCost |
+--------+-------------+-----------+
| A | B | 1 |
| A | C | 4 |
| B | C | 2 |
| A | D | 4 |
| A | C | 2 |
+--------+-------------+-----------+
The result I am looking for is
Origin | Destination | Price |
A C 3
As A-->B = 1, B-->C=2 , So A-->C=1+2=3 in the last row.
How do I achieve this? I tried using SUM(LeastCost) inside the recursive query but MySQl doesn't allow aggregations in there.
mysql
what about A->C = 4? (second row)
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:03
That's the A->C I am talking about. Sorry, will edit the question
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:06
do you want minimum cost?
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:07
1
Yes. I want the minimum cost as my final answer, but I thought I'd do that once I figure out how to deal with this.
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:08
what is the max level of hierarchy in your database? is it 3 level maximum?
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:11
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
My problem statement is: I need to find places I can visit from Origin 'A' and their respective costs.
This is my table Train(Origin, Destination, LeastCost)
+--------+-------------+------+
| Origin | Destination | cost |
+--------+-------------+------+
| A | B | 1 |
| A | C | 4 |
| B | C | 2 |
| A | D | 4 |
+--------+-------------+------+
I have tried a query:
with recursive Final(Origin, Destination, LeastCost) As(
-> (Select * from Train)
-> UNION
-> (Select T.Origin, F.Destination, F.LeastCost
-> from Train T, Final F
-> where T.Destination = F.Origin))
-> select * from Final ;
This gives me:
+--------+-------------+-----------+
| Origin | Destination | LeastCost |
+--------+-------------+-----------+
| A | B | 1 |
| A | C | 4 |
| B | C | 2 |
| A | D | 4 |
| A | C | 2 |
+--------+-------------+-----------+
The result I am looking for is
Origin | Destination | Price |
A C 3
As A-->B = 1, B-->C=2 , So A-->C=1+2=3 in the last row.
How do I achieve this? I tried using SUM(LeastCost) inside the recursive query but MySQl doesn't allow aggregations in there.
mysql
My problem statement is: I need to find places I can visit from Origin 'A' and their respective costs.
This is my table Train(Origin, Destination, LeastCost)
+--------+-------------+------+
| Origin | Destination | cost |
+--------+-------------+------+
| A | B | 1 |
| A | C | 4 |
| B | C | 2 |
| A | D | 4 |
+--------+-------------+------+
I have tried a query:
with recursive Final(Origin, Destination, LeastCost) As(
-> (Select * from Train)
-> UNION
-> (Select T.Origin, F.Destination, F.LeastCost
-> from Train T, Final F
-> where T.Destination = F.Origin))
-> select * from Final ;
This gives me:
+--------+-------------+-----------+
| Origin | Destination | LeastCost |
+--------+-------------+-----------+
| A | B | 1 |
| A | C | 4 |
| B | C | 2 |
| A | D | 4 |
| A | C | 2 |
+--------+-------------+-----------+
The result I am looking for is
Origin | Destination | Price |
A C 3
As A-->B = 1, B-->C=2 , So A-->C=1+2=3 in the last row.
How do I achieve this? I tried using SUM(LeastCost) inside the recursive query but MySQl doesn't allow aggregations in there.
mysql
mysql
edited Nov 10 at 19:06
asked Nov 10 at 19:01
SUIIIII
175
175
what about A->C = 4? (second row)
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:03
That's the A->C I am talking about. Sorry, will edit the question
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:06
do you want minimum cost?
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:07
1
Yes. I want the minimum cost as my final answer, but I thought I'd do that once I figure out how to deal with this.
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:08
what is the max level of hierarchy in your database? is it 3 level maximum?
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:11
add a comment |
what about A->C = 4? (second row)
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:03
That's the A->C I am talking about. Sorry, will edit the question
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:06
do you want minimum cost?
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:07
1
Yes. I want the minimum cost as my final answer, but I thought I'd do that once I figure out how to deal with this.
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:08
what is the max level of hierarchy in your database? is it 3 level maximum?
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:11
what about A->C = 4? (second row)
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:03
what about A->C = 4? (second row)
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:03
That's the A->C I am talking about. Sorry, will edit the question
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:06
That's the A->C I am talking about. Sorry, will edit the question
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:06
do you want minimum cost?
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:07
do you want minimum cost?
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:07
1
1
Yes. I want the minimum cost as my final answer, but I thought I'd do that once I figure out how to deal with this.
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:08
Yes. I want the minimum cost as my final answer, but I thought I'd do that once I figure out how to deal with this.
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:08
what is the max level of hierarchy in your database? is it 3 level maximum?
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:11
what is the max level of hierarchy in your database? is it 3 level maximum?
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:11
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
up vote
1
down vote
accepted
Add the two costs from the T and F aliases together in the recursive query.
And then put additional logic in the final query to group the results:
with recursive Final(Origin, Destination, LeastCost) As(
(Select * from Train)
UNION
(Select T.Origin, F.Destination, T.cost + F.LeastCost
from Train T, Final F
where T.Destination = F.Origin)
)
select Origin, Destination, min(LeastCost)
from Final
group by Origin, Destination
Through the recursive mechanism T.cost + F.LeastCost
will make the cost sum up as you travel from one node through the tree to another.
Unknown column 'T.LeastCost' in 'field list' This is what I am getting.
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:56
1
Should becost
, notLeastCost
. I corrected it just now.
– trincot
Nov 10 at 19:58
thank you so much! :)
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 20:02
1
You're welcome ;-)
– trincot
Nov 10 at 20:03
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
1
down vote
accepted
Add the two costs from the T and F aliases together in the recursive query.
And then put additional logic in the final query to group the results:
with recursive Final(Origin, Destination, LeastCost) As(
(Select * from Train)
UNION
(Select T.Origin, F.Destination, T.cost + F.LeastCost
from Train T, Final F
where T.Destination = F.Origin)
)
select Origin, Destination, min(LeastCost)
from Final
group by Origin, Destination
Through the recursive mechanism T.cost + F.LeastCost
will make the cost sum up as you travel from one node through the tree to another.
Unknown column 'T.LeastCost' in 'field list' This is what I am getting.
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:56
1
Should becost
, notLeastCost
. I corrected it just now.
– trincot
Nov 10 at 19:58
thank you so much! :)
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 20:02
1
You're welcome ;-)
– trincot
Nov 10 at 20:03
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
accepted
Add the two costs from the T and F aliases together in the recursive query.
And then put additional logic in the final query to group the results:
with recursive Final(Origin, Destination, LeastCost) As(
(Select * from Train)
UNION
(Select T.Origin, F.Destination, T.cost + F.LeastCost
from Train T, Final F
where T.Destination = F.Origin)
)
select Origin, Destination, min(LeastCost)
from Final
group by Origin, Destination
Through the recursive mechanism T.cost + F.LeastCost
will make the cost sum up as you travel from one node through the tree to another.
Unknown column 'T.LeastCost' in 'field list' This is what I am getting.
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:56
1
Should becost
, notLeastCost
. I corrected it just now.
– trincot
Nov 10 at 19:58
thank you so much! :)
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 20:02
1
You're welcome ;-)
– trincot
Nov 10 at 20:03
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
accepted
up vote
1
down vote
accepted
Add the two costs from the T and F aliases together in the recursive query.
And then put additional logic in the final query to group the results:
with recursive Final(Origin, Destination, LeastCost) As(
(Select * from Train)
UNION
(Select T.Origin, F.Destination, T.cost + F.LeastCost
from Train T, Final F
where T.Destination = F.Origin)
)
select Origin, Destination, min(LeastCost)
from Final
group by Origin, Destination
Through the recursive mechanism T.cost + F.LeastCost
will make the cost sum up as you travel from one node through the tree to another.
Add the two costs from the T and F aliases together in the recursive query.
And then put additional logic in the final query to group the results:
with recursive Final(Origin, Destination, LeastCost) As(
(Select * from Train)
UNION
(Select T.Origin, F.Destination, T.cost + F.LeastCost
from Train T, Final F
where T.Destination = F.Origin)
)
select Origin, Destination, min(LeastCost)
from Final
group by Origin, Destination
Through the recursive mechanism T.cost + F.LeastCost
will make the cost sum up as you travel from one node through the tree to another.
edited Nov 10 at 19:58
answered Nov 10 at 19:15
trincot
114k1477109
114k1477109
Unknown column 'T.LeastCost' in 'field list' This is what I am getting.
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:56
1
Should becost
, notLeastCost
. I corrected it just now.
– trincot
Nov 10 at 19:58
thank you so much! :)
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 20:02
1
You're welcome ;-)
– trincot
Nov 10 at 20:03
add a comment |
Unknown column 'T.LeastCost' in 'field list' This is what I am getting.
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:56
1
Should becost
, notLeastCost
. I corrected it just now.
– trincot
Nov 10 at 19:58
thank you so much! :)
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 20:02
1
You're welcome ;-)
– trincot
Nov 10 at 20:03
Unknown column 'T.LeastCost' in 'field list' This is what I am getting.
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:56
Unknown column 'T.LeastCost' in 'field list' This is what I am getting.
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:56
1
1
Should be
cost
, not LeastCost
. I corrected it just now.– trincot
Nov 10 at 19:58
Should be
cost
, not LeastCost
. I corrected it just now.– trincot
Nov 10 at 19:58
thank you so much! :)
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 20:02
thank you so much! :)
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 20:02
1
1
You're welcome ;-)
– trincot
Nov 10 at 20:03
You're welcome ;-)
– trincot
Nov 10 at 20:03
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Stack Overflow!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.
Please pay close attention to the following guidance:
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fstackoverflow.com%2fquestions%2f53242413%2fhow-to-sum-in-mysql-recursive-query%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
what about A->C = 4? (second row)
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:03
That's the A->C I am talking about. Sorry, will edit the question
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:06
do you want minimum cost?
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:07
1
Yes. I want the minimum cost as my final answer, but I thought I'd do that once I figure out how to deal with this.
– SUIIIII
Nov 10 at 19:08
what is the max level of hierarchy in your database? is it 3 level maximum?
– FatemehNB
Nov 10 at 19:11